New Haven Ice Cream Cakes

Build your dream ice cream cake from the brownie, er. Bottom up.

Order a Cake

Ben & Jerry’s Cakes

Who knew ice cream cakes could be so mind-blowing? If you don’t want just any old cake, you’ve come to the right place. Whether you’re looking for a custom ice cream cake that is as unique in flavor and design as your upscale party, or a fun ready-to-go ice cream cake, we have it. Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Cakes are perfect for Office Parties, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Valentine’s Day, Graduation Parties, Birthdays and much more. Our ice cream cakes serve 2-40+!

Non-Dairy cakes!  Call the store for options and pricing.  There is a $10.00 surcharge for non-dairy options.

Once a cake order is placed, it cannot be changed or canceled.

Ice cream cake on a table with party supplies

Build Your Own Cake Here

Order online or call the shop at: 203 712 4300

An ice cream cake with a slice from it on a plate next to a cup

Choose One of Our Cake Designs

Designs for every occasion.

An ice cream cake with a slice from it on a plate

Create Your Custom Cake

Custom design your own ice cream cake.

Shape & Size

What shape and size do you want?
Sheet
Round
Heart
Sorry, some designs are not available in every shape.

Flavors

Select one of our favorite combos:
Or select up to 2 flavors:

Fillings/Color/Toppings

Filling
Select one filling:
Body Color
Select one body color:
Vanilla
Border Color
Select one border color:
Vanilla
Toppings
Select up to 3 toppings:

Fillings

Our cakes come with a tasty filling between your ice cream layers as well as on the bottom of your cake. What would you like?

Select one:

Message

Choose a message or write your own.

If you would like a name added to the message, please use the 'Write Your Own' option.
Write your own!
( is the maximum number of characters per cake.  characters remaining.)

You're almost done. Just provide a few details below and hit submit order.

* = Required Field

Pickup Location

New Haven Ice Cream Shop New Haven, CT 06510 203 712 4300

Available Pickup Dates/Times

  • Sunday: 12:00pm - 12:00am
  • Monday: 12:00pm - 12:00am
  • Tuesday: 12:00pm - 12:00am
  • Wednesday: 12:00pm - 12:00am
  • Thursday: 12:00pm - 12:00am
  • Friday: 12:00pm - 1:00am
  • Saturday: 12:00pm - 1:00am

Cake orders require a 48 hour lead-time. In a cake emergency and need it today? Call ahead to see what's in stock.

Please enter your requested pickup date in the format mm/dd/yyyy, or click to use the calendar to select your pickup date.
Please select your requested pickup time. Pickup times are available every half hour during normal business hours.
Anything else you'd like us to know before we create your cake? As a reminder, if you have a dietary or allergy concerns, we request that you place your order by phone with our shop.
You must accept this to receive information from Ben and Jerry’s.
$
Oops! Please enter a valid tip value.
Order Subtotal:
Order Tax:
Order Total:

Payment (Powered by Square)