Our Top 10 Favorite Scoop Shop Exclusive Flavors

Talk about a decadent treat. This flavor takes bourbon brown butter ice cream, adds dark chocolate whiskey cordial cups, and finishes it off with a bourbon brown butter swirl. We like to think this masterpiece makes Kentucky proud.

We have a knack for turning our favorite desserts into ice creams, even those of the multi-layered variety. With coconut ice cream, coconut and fudge flakes, walnuts, and swirls of graham cracker and butterscotch, you’ll be on cloud nine before you can finish counting the seven layers of euphoria.

Remember the simple pleasure of dunking your chocolate cookies in milk as a kid? Or maybe last week… This is that – in ice cream form. Try this cookie-tastic treat in a milkshake for even higher levels of cookie-phoria.

Speaking of childhood nostalgia, remember stuffing wads of cotton candy into your mouth and marveling at how it melted away without a trace? Experience that same delicious melting phenomenon with this cotton candy ice cream stuffed with cotton candy pieces.

You ‘butter’ believe that ‘pecan’ put a smile on any nut-lover’s face with this flavor. Rich buttery ice cream filled with not just regular pecans, but perfectly roasted pecans. That’s nuttin’ to sneeze at.

First the sweetness dances on your tongue like a delicate ballerina. Then the tartness arrives, pursing your lips into a euphoric pucker. For those warm summer days (or a reminder of them in cooler months), there’s Lemonade Sorbet.

Chocolate and peanut butter go together like, well, chocolate and peanut butter! Or like Ben and Jerry. Or like a smile and an ‘Mmmmm’. All of which you’ll experience when you try this perfect marriage of milk chocolate ice cream with a thick peanut buttery swirl.

Some days just feel like sorbet days. Like the hottest days of summer. Or when you’re craving a tropical vacation experience. Try this swirl of blueberry and raspberry sorbets on its own or blended into a succulent smoothie.

It’s not often that you encounter a Ben & Jerry’s flavor quite so simply perfect. Sure, we like to play with chunks and swirls and hunks and whirls, but sometimes we also like to return to ice cream’s simple pleasures. Like creamy strawberry ice cream loaded with strawberry pieces.

It’s okay to order this flavor because you feel a need to freshen up your breath. It’s also okay if you’re a die-hard mint lover looking for a burst of ice cream euphoria. We won’t ask your reasons when you order this cool combination of peppermint ice cream and satisfying fudge chunks.