The numbers are in! We’ve counted every chunk and swirl that you scooped up this year (yup, we even saw those late night right-out-of-the-pint bites), and we know exactly which flavors are the rockstars of 2019. Are you ready? Grab a pint of your favorite flavor and dig in:
10. Milk & Cookies
Milk & Cookies makes its top 10 debut! We’re not sure why this cookie-filled classic cracked the top 10 this year, but it probably has something to do with how great cookies are.
9. Mint Chocolate Cookie
Fans really mixed it up in 2019! Mint Chocolate Cookie, too, made the top 10 list for the first time ever. Maybe it’s mint to be?
8. Americone Dream
The dream lives on! Fans couldn’t get enough of those caramel swirls and fudge-covered waffle cone pieces this year.
7. Strawberry Cheesecake
Come for the strawberry cheesecake ice cream, stay for the thick graham cracker swirls. And when we say thick, we mean thick.
6. Phish Food
Holding steady at #6, Phish Food proves once again that fans cannot get enough marshmallow swirls and fudge fish. Just don’t feed it to your actual fish, okay?
5. Chocolate Fudge Brownie
The day that fans stop loving chocolate ice cream with fudge brownies is the day the world stops turning. Rock on, chocolate lovers.
4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
We’ve been churning it up since 1984, and fans have been loving it ever since. Thankfully we’ve updated our hair ‘dos a bit since 1984, though.
3. The Tonight Dough
Up from #5 last year, The Tonight Dough is rising through the ranks! What’s next? #1? Only dough lovers can say.
2. Cherry Garcia
Holding steady at #2 for the last several years, Cherry Garcia is just about as well-loved as its guitar legend namesake, Jerry Garcia. Which is to say: extremely well-loved.
1. Half Baked
The champion. The pinnacle of pint prowess. The flavor that unapologetically reigns over the ice cream aisle. Ladies and gentlemen, Half Baked.