Our Top 10 Cookie Dough Flavors

The one, the only. The OG cookie dough pint. Fans have been raving about this classic flavor ever since an anonymous fan suggested it way back in 1984. And now it’s also available as a certified vegan Non-Dairy pint, so everyone can do the dough.

Half Baked takes Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and adds chocolate ice cream and fudgy brownies, two things that have never, ever made an ice cream flavor worse. The result? Our most popular flavor ever.

There’s only one thing that The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon is missing: Entertainment for your taste buds. Keep them laughing with Jimmy’s signature flavor and its new-for-2021 Tonight Dough Non-Dairy sidekick.

When you want to go for the dough, the whole dough, and nothing but the dough, reach for a pouch of Cookie Dough Chunks, available in a whole heck of a lot of flavors. It’s all of the dough, with none of the digging. Pro tip: Let them warm up for 10 minutes or so for an extra gooey texture.

But if you still want some ice cream with your cookie dough, check out these 3 Cookie Dough Cores flavors for the maximum dough-to-ice-cream ratio. Each one has a thick core of cookie dough in the middle and deliciosity rates that are off the charts.

If you love Half Baked, this unbaked spin on the original is sure to get your dough-o-meter spinning. We took Half Baked and swapped brownie batter swirls for the fudgy brownies and the results are batter than we could ever have imagined.

Just when you thought we didn’t have any more cookie dough tricks up our sleeves, we come through with Chocolate Caramel Cookie Dough Topped. It’s bursting with cookie dough and topped with a delicious chocolatey ganache. Top that!

Okay, okay, this one isn’t really cookie dough. But it is dough. And cinnamon bun dough has a lot in common with cookie dough. For starters, it’s dough. Also, it’s wildly delicious and absolutely worth trying as you search for your absolute favorite cookie dough ice cream flavor.

If you haven’t noticed, we love finding new ways to spin Half Baked. For our next trick, we take the classic pint and peanut butter it until it can be peanut butter’d no more. Find it in dairy and certified vegan Non-Dairy pints!

Speaking of peanut butter, for a tasty treat with fewer calories and less fat than other ice creams, P.B. Dough Moo-phoria light ice cream has you covered. It’s packed with peanut butter and chocolate euphoria!