Quick: what are your top 10 favorite Ben & Jerry’s flavors? You know them by heart, right? Of course you do. That’s because you’re a savvy ice cream lover, one who can parse the gentle differences between Half Baked and Everything But The… and talk at length about the subtle nuances of chocolate, fudge, and ganache. And most importantly of all, you know what you like.
So when it comes to Ben & Jerry’s flavors, you could probably rate every single flavor according to how well it tickles your taste buds. And did you know that you can do just that? Fans have been rating our flavors for some time now, from Red Velvet Cake to Pistachio Pistachio to Milk & Cookies — just click the “Ratings & Reviews” button on each flavor’s web page.
How Do You Stack Up?
Do you think your tastes line up pretty well with the rest of the Ben & Jerry’s fandom? Or are you an outlier who loves the little guys? According to our fans, other Ben & Jerry’s lovers just like yourself, these are the top 10 absolute best Ben & Jerry’s flavors:
10. Oat of This Swirled
With oatmeal cinnamon cookie swirls beyond our wildest dreams, it’s no wonder this buttery, cinnamon-y treat is highly rated. Could it be fans of the now-de-pinted Oatmeal Cookie Swirl leading the charge? Highly possible.
9. Frozen Flakes
8. Chunky Monkey
If the banana ice cream doesn’t grab you, those hearty chunks of fudge and walnuts sure will. Banana lovers have been fanatic over this a-peel-ing treat ever since it launched in 1988.
7. Vanilla Caramel Fudge
Chunks are great, but there’s something special about this smooth operator, too. Simply superior vanilla ice cream with swirls of caramel and fudge — sign us up and hand us a spoon.
6. Half Baked
The classic collision of Chocolate Fudge Brownie and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough has long been a fan fave. The collision of your spoon with the bottom of the pint, though? That’s much less liked.
5. Caramel Almond Brittle Non-Dairy
This year’s brand spoonin’ new Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy flavors have been a huge hit. And Caramel Almond Brittle’s salted caramel swirl and almond brittle pieces has had fans saying, “Almond love with you” more than almost any other.
4. Coconut Seven Layer Bar Non-Dairy
Seven layers of euphoria! Coconut Seven Layer Bar has it all — coconut, fudge, walnuts, graham cracker, and caramel — and an enthusiastic thumbs up from Non-Dairy lovers everywhere.
3. Chubby Hubby
Vanilla malt ice cream. Pretzels. Peanut butter. There’s nothing about this flavor that makes us say anything other than, “Get in my belly right now.” No wonder it’s number three according to our peanut-loving fans.
2. Boom Chocolatta Cookie Core
Boom! A whole chocolatta our fans are really into Boom Chocolatta Cookie Core, and we totally know why. It’s gotta be the chocolate cookie core, right? Or the mocha and caramel ice creams. Or how fun it is to say “Boom Chocolatta”. Yeah, that’s probably it.
1. The Tonight Dough
According to our dough-loving fans, The Tonight Dough is the best of the best. The dough-iest of the dough. A dough-ble whammy of caramel and chocolate ice creams, plus chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough. After all, you can never have enough dough.