QUIZ: Which Blast From The Past Pint Should You Try First?

They’re back! You asked us to resurrect Peanut Butter Half Baked, Gimme S’more, and Cannoli, so we got right to work churning them up. We can’t resist them either! But now the question is which one should you dig in to first? Thankfully, there’s no wrong answer. Take the quiz to find your best match!

1: When you make a sundae, which topping do you go for first?

Chocolate fudge

Crushed cookies

Peanut butter cups

2: What best describes your favorite Ben & Jerry’s flavor?

It’s been my favorite flavors since forever, I even remember eating it as a kid

It’s the flavor with the most chunks, swirls, and wild surprises under the lid

I like whatever’s on trend at the moment

3: How do you eat your Ben & Jerry’s?

In a fancy gelato dish, with my favorite silver spoon

Right out of the pint

In my favorite ice cream bowl, which I made in ceramics class when I was 9

4: You go to buy a pint of Ben & Jerry’s and they don’t have your favorite flavor. How do you pick which pint to get?

I have a laminated list of my top 10 in my pocket at all times, so I just move down the list

I look for the one with the longest description — that means there’s a lot of stuff in there

I look for the ones that say “New” on the lid

5: What’s your perfect Saturday?

Brunch with friends and then a foreign film at the local art house (bonus points if there are subtitles!)

Lunch with my BFF where we reminisce about the old days

Skydiving in the morning, then building the world’s largest ice cream sundae in the afternoon

6: What’s your go-to order at the Scoop Shop?

A milkshake made with my favorite flavor

Whatever their newest, coolest menu item is

A sundae with all the fixings

7: You and your BFF are splitting a pint. Which flavor do you get?

My favorite flavor

Their favorite flavor

One that I know we both like, because this is not our first rodeo re: splitting a pint

8: What is your favorite thing to put ice cream on?

Between two donuts, it’s the best ice cream sandwich ever

A Dutch stroopwafel

My favorite breakfast cereal

9: Your favorite restaurant recently updated their dessert menu to include only these three options. Which one do you try first?

A gourmet s’mores sandwich made with toasted marshmallow

A fudgy brownie with peanut buttery swirls

A trio of mini cannoli with authentic Sicilian filling

10: When you saw that we had re-introduced three flavors from years past, which one were you the most excited about?

Cannoli

Peanut Butter Half Baked

Gimme S'more

8 Ice Cream and Beer Pairings Perfect for Oktoberfest

5 Things You Definitely Didn’t Know About the Ampersand

QUIZ: Which Underrated Flavor Should You Try Next?

QUIZ: Tell Us About Your Ideal Summer Hang And We’ll Tell You What Flavor To Bring

Comments

QUIZ: Which Blast From The Past Pint Should You Try First?

You Should Go For: Peanut Butter Half Baked!

You Should Go For: Gimme S’more!

You Should Go For: Cannoli!

Related Articles

Most Popular

Recent Tweets